SHOCKING: Cowboys Take High-Stakes Gamble on Another Five-star in Trade That Sparks Early Doubts

 

It took less than 24 hours for the Dallas Cowboys’ trade for George Pickens to be questioned — and potentially criticized.

 

While Dallas chose not to spend a premium pick on a wide receiver in the 2025 NFL Draft, they made a bold move to bolster their receiving corps by acquiring Pickens from the Pittsburgh Steelers in exchange for a 2026 third-round pick. On paper, the trade gives CeeDee Lamb a much-needed running mate — but not everyone is sold on the deal.

 

ESPN’s Seth Walder quickly handed the Steelers a B+ grade for the trade, while Dallas received a more modest B-. Known for valuing draft capital, Walder’s analysis suggests the Cowboys may have overpaid for a player with both promise and baggage.

Pickens, still just 24 and entering the final year of his rookie contract, has shown flashes of brilliance, tallying 2,841 receiving yards and 12 touchdowns over three seasons — despite inconsistent quarterback play in Pittsburgh. With Dak Prescott now throwing his way, Pickens has a chance to finally thrive as a true No. 2 option behind Lamb.

 

However, questions linger. While Pickens has avoided off-field controversies, his emotional style of play and occasional outbursts have raised concerns. Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin’s decision to move on from a young, talented receiver still on a rookie deal speaks volumes — and the Cowboys must now hope they can harness his intensity in a positive way.

 

If Pickens buys into the system and earns a long-term role in Dallas, his physicality paired with Lamb’s explosiveness could give the Cowboys the firepower they need to overcome the predictability of new offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer’s scheme.

 

Dallas paid a premium to land Pickens, but the story isn’t over yet. If he blossoms into a true X receiver, the trade could end up looking like a masterstroke. For now, though, the pressure is on — and the clock is ticking.